Home Internet App Store bills gets ghosted, Dispo drama, Facebook’s Clubhouse clone – TechCrunch

App Store bills gets ghosted, Dispo drama, Facebook’s Clubhouse clone – TechCrunch


Welcome back to This Week in Apps, the weekly TechCrunch series that recaps the latest mobile O.S. O.S.ws, mobile applications, and the overall app economy. The app industry is as hot as ever, with 218 billion downloads and $143 billion in global consumer spending in 2020.

Consumers last year also spent 3.5 trillion minutes using apps on Android devices alone. And in the thU.S.SU.S.pp usage surged ahead of the time spent watching live.VTV.T.Vurrently, the average American watches 3.7 hours of liT.V. T.V. T.V. day but now spends four hours daily on their mobile devices.

Apps aren’t just a way to pass idle hours — they’re also a big business. In 2019, mobile-first companies had a combined $544 billion valuation, 6.5x higher than those without a mobile focus. In 2020, investors poured $73 billion in capital into mobile companies — a figure up 27% year-over-year. This week we’re looking at the case of the missing Arizona app store bill, the latest on the Dispo drama, and Facebook’s new audio efforts, among other things.

This Week in Apps will soon be a newsletter! Sign up here: techcrunch.com/newsletters

So, where did that App Store legislation go?

Arizona’s Senate was supposed to vote on a controversial bill, HB2005, making it the first state to regulate the Apple and Google app stores. But the vote was listed first on the Senate’s Livestream agenda on Wednesday, March 24, but the voice never came up.

Basecamp co-founder and Apple critic David Heinemeier Hansson, who submitted testimony in supporH.B.ofH.B.B H.B.05, basically called the lobbying system corrupt.

That doesn’t mean it’s guaranteed that it’s over in Arizona, but hot diggity, damn. Seeing how the corrupt… I mean.. lobbying works this close, and this brazenly is something else. But Apple can’t buy all the legislators in all the states. Refuse to believe that. — DHH (@dhh) March 24, 2021

Apple and Google had indeed hired lobbyists to combat the bill, which would have threatened the companies’ ability to continue collecting their 15% or 30% commissions by allowing app developers to use third-party payment processors for sales and in-app purchases.

Apple had its lobbyist, Rod Diridon, working on the Arizona bill, and was said to have hired Kirk Adams, a former chief of staff to Arizona Gov. Doug Ducey, to negotiate directly with the bill’s sponsor, Rep. Regina Cobb (R).

However, others countered the narrative being laid out by Hansson, saying that the bill’s existence in the first place was the result of lobbying from Epic Games and others, and many lawmakers didn’t even know what they were voting on. A similar bill was already voted down in North Dakota, and HB2005 didn’t seem to have much support either, ahead of the would-be vote. The Coalition for App Fairness (CAF), a group backing these bills, told us it didn’t know what happened to the account but was trying to find out.


Pretty weird that this bill ghosted!

Then again, an App Store bill getting mysteriously rejected without sufficient explanation is …fitting. https://t.co/C7ycLqTILc

— Dieter Bohn (@backlon) March 24, 2021

Dispo loses investor support, Dobrik

Once-hot mobile photos app Dispo is becoming a case study of why partnering with high-profile influencers and YouTuber types without due diligence is a bad idea. When a recent investigation revealed that a YouTuber, David Dobrik’s “Vlog Squad,” sexually assaulted her, Dispo’s early investors distanced themselves from the app.

Initially, lead investor Spark Capital said it would “sever all ties” with the company, TechCrunch’s Natasha Mascarenhas reported earlier this week. Dobrik also left the board and the company hours later. Two other investors, Seven Seven Six and Unshackled, said they would donate any potential profits from their Dispo investment into organizations working with survivors of sexual assault.

(Cynically, one could argue, the firms don’t expect much left to donate with this much of a stain on Dispo’s public image and the loss of its big-name backer in Dobrik). Dispo had been valued at $200 million after its $20 million Series A, led by Spark Capital, only weeks ago. The company released a statement saying it would continue to work on the platform.

Facebook’s Clubhouse rival looks like Clubhouse.

New screenshots of Facebook’s unreleased audio product, still under development, show what appears to be a live audio broadcast experience that’s more of an extension of Facebook’s existing Messenger Rooms rather than a standalone app experience. The photos show Clubhouse-like audio rooms with rounded profile icons and a listener section led by the speakers’ friends — like Clubhouse. Facebook confirmed the images are examples of the company’s “exploratory audio efforts” but cautioned that they don’t represent a live product now.

While the company said not to jump to conclusions about what this all means regarding a final product, it’s interesting to see how Facebook thinks about social audio experiences and where they could fit in on its platform. In this case, it sees it as a third option in Messenger Rooms — users could start a private video chat with friends or a private audio chat or go live to the public on audio-only.

Mark Zuckerberg (rather boldly) went on Clubhouse to praise Clubhouse for what it had pioneered, saying it would end up “being one of the modalities around the live audio broadcast.” It seems Facebook sees Clubhouse as just another networking format to be knocked off, like TikTok’s vertical videos or Snapchat Stories, which Facebook later adopted for its platforms.

Platforms: Apple

People noticed that recently created Shortcuts links broke this week, displaying the “Shortcut Not Found” message instead of opening the Shortcuts app. The issue impacted everyone who has shared shortcuts. Apple said it was aware of the problem and working on a fix.

Apple rolled out its fifth developer betas for iOS 14.5, iPadOS 14.5, and other platforms, which was then shortly followed by the release of the public betas. These may be the last betas before the public launch, though Apple has gone beyond five betas in the past.

Apple responded to the Australian Competition & Consumer Commission (ACCC), which is investigating the potentially anti-competitive nature of the App Store, by saying that there were other options for developers to reach iOS users — like using a website. Some developers were not amused.

“[We] face competitive constraints from distribution alternatives within the iOS ecosystem (including developer websites and other outlets through which consumers may obtain third-party apps and use them on their iOS devices) and outside iOS.”

This smacks of disingenuousness. https://t.co/spMxnJDGKo

— Dan Masters – OhMDee.com (@OhMDee) March 25, 2021

Apple also defended its App Review process to the ACCC, saying that it reviews 73% of prospective apps within 24 hours of being submitted by a developer and offers details as to why an app didn’t comply with its guidelines. It also argued that it provides a worldwide support line that facilitates 1,000 calls per week in all 175 countries where the App Store operates.

A tentative initial witness list in Apple’s courtroom battle with Epic Games over Apple’s alleged monopolist practices includes Apple CEO Tim Cook, Software Engineering SVP Craig Federighi, and Apple Fellow Phil Schiller (who helped launch and run the App Store). Epic will be calling its CEO Tim Sweeney and VP Mark Rein. Executives from Microsoft, Facebook, and Nvidia are also included.

Platforms: Google

Google announced the AndroidS.E.eady SE S.E.liance to ensure that new phones will be ready to support digital alternatives like car keys, house keys, wallets (think I.D.sional IDsI.D.sobile driver’s licenses, passports), and more.

This requires that phones include tamper-resistant hardware called a SecurS.E.Element S.E.E)S.E.nd StrongBox, an implementation of the Keymaster HAL that resides in a hardware security module launched with the Pixel 3 in 2018.

Many Android apps, including Gmail and Google Pay, began crashing this week due to an issue with Android System WebView. Google addressed the problem by issuing updates for the standalone WebView app and Google Chrome.


H&M was removed from significant e-commerce apps and platforms in China, including Alibaba’s Taobao, JD.com, Pinduoduo, Meituan’s shop-listing app Dianping, map apps from Tencent and Baidu, among other major online platforms. The Swedish retailer had decided to stop buying cotton from Xinjiang, where over 1 million members of the Uyghur and other predominantly Muslim ethnic minorities have been confined to detention camps, which are accused of imposing forced labor.

Nike, Adidas, Burberry, Uniqlo, and Lacoste also criticized China for expressing concern over Xinjiang, leading dozen of celebs to cancel endorsement deals. NBCU agreed with Facebook and Instagram to extend its “shoppable opportunities” to social media platforms. The e-commerce partnership will put pitcT.V.s from the TV T.V.mpany’s clients on its social handles on Facebook and Instagram.


Robinhood, the free trading app and recent home to the GameStop frenzy, confidentially filed for an IPO. After several media outlets broke the news, the company confirmed the filing in a blog post.


TikTok belatedly banned some Myanmar accounts that posted violent videos supporting the military’s violent coup, saying it was aggressively cracking down on accounts promoting violence. The takedowns of the video — some of which threatened protesters with death or spread hate-fueled claims — didn’t start until early March, a month after the coup began.

TikTok added an Ad Library tool that allows marketers to view the top-performing ad campaigns across the app. The “top ads” feature can also be filtered by vertical and region, then by time (last seven or 30 days) and performance (CTR, impressions, video view rate).

Snapchat is developing its take on TikTok Duets with the test of a Snap Remix feature. Duets are a core part of what makes TikTok feel like a social network rather than just a platform for more passive video viewing. Remix — which shares the name with an Instagram Duets-style feature that’s soon to launch publicly — lets users repurpose others’ Snaps for use through various formats.

Bloomberg reports that Facebook is testing an app for prisoners who are re-entering society. The “Re-Entry App” was shared at the top of some users’ Instagram feeds this week, offering early access.

Axios reported that Trump talked with no-name app vendors about creating his social networking app. The app includes a news feed, user profiles, and group messaging features. The app consists of a news feed, user profiles, and group messaging features. One of the companies he spoke to was the largely unknown platform FreeSpace, which claims its network is designed to “reinforce good habits and make the world a better place.”

Parler says it sent the FBI over 50 posts about the Capitol riot ahead of January 6, The NYT reports. If accurate, it raises the question of whether or not the FBI took the threats seriously. The FBI has refused to comment on Parler’s statement. Meanwhile, Parler faces a lawsuit by former CEO John Matze, who claims conservative donor RU.K.ah Mercer forced him out.

U.KU.K.tchdog says Facebook’s acquisition of Giphy raises competition concerns. The Competition and Markets Authority launched the first phase of its investigation in January and notes that Giphy had competed with FaceboU.K.utside the U.KU.K. digital ad deals. Twitter seems to be working on an audience picker for its upcoming communities feature, reports Jane Manchun Wong. This would be accessible from within the tweet composer screen.

Streaming & Entertainment

Spotify updated its mobile app with several changes to the Home hub. These include a way to rediscover recently played songs as far back as three months ago; a way for Premium users to view new and unfinished podcasts with a blue dot (new) and progress bar (incomplete); and a new section of personalized music recommendations. The company later in the week also updated its desktop and web app.

Triller forges licensing agreements with music publishers, Variety reports. The deal with the National Music Publishers’ Association, representing most American publishers, follows Universal withdrawing its entire library from the app last month, claiming Triller withheld payments. Triller claimed to have no idea why UMG would do this. Clubhouse says its Android launch will “take a couple of months.” Before, the company had said it would be “soon” without promising any time frame.


Genshin Impact tops $1 billion on mobile in less than six months following its September 2020 launch, says Sensor Tower. During the last 30 days, the game ranked No. 3 on the App Store and Google Play combined, behind Tencent’s PUBG Mobile and Honor of Kings.

Gaming voice and text chat service Discord, which has expanded into other forms of social networking, is said to be exploring a sale that could be worth over $10 billion. Bloomberg reported Microsoft was in talks to buy the service for more than $10 billion, but no deal was imminent, and Discord may choose to go public instead.

PUBG Mobile has grossed $5 billion in revenue after generating an average of $7.4 million per day in 2020, Sensor Tower reports. Like many games, PUBG Mobile’s revenue soared during the height of the pandemic, with record spending of $300 million last March during lockdowns.

Google Stadia may soon get touchscreen controls on Android, 9to5Google found by digging into the Android app’s code. The rules would allow users to use gestures like tapping, swiping, and pinching.


Apple updated its Schoolwork and Classroom apps with a few more features to make it easier to share projects and support remote learning, among other things. The company also announced a Teacher Portfolio badge awarded to teachers who completed a series of lessons focused on learning foundational skills on iPad and Mac.

Health & Fitness

Tile’s lost item-tracking service arrived on wearables for the first time, thanks to a new partnership with Google’s Fitbit. Through a Fitbit app update, new and existing Fitbit Inspire 2 owners will access Tile’s Bluetooth-based finding network to locate their misplaced Fitbit.

In the IoT and fitness-tracking app space, Mi Fit, Strava, MyFitnessPal, Google Fit, Fitbit, BetterMe, Runtastic, Nike Training Club, Step Tracker by Leap Fitness, and Samsung Health saw the most downloads last year. According to App Annie, health and fitness apps downloads increased by 20% in 2020 due to the pandemic and users shifting to at-home workouts. Data from Uswitch notes that demand for sleep apps increased by 104% during the pandemic, while demand for wellness apps grew 26% since March 2020.


Slack CEO Stewart Butterfield teased new Slack features in beta testing: an asynchronous audio messages feature, a Clubhouse-like drop-in voice chat, and Slack Stories. The exec announced the news in the PressClub show on Clubhouse, adding, “Good artists copy, great artists steal.”

Slack also launched aD.M.ew universal DM D.M.steD.M.salled Connect DMsD.M.shich allows any Slack user to direct message any other Slack user. The system was immediately called out for potentially enabling harassment and abuse, leading the company to pull the ability to customize the invite message.

Cortana has begun to warn its iOS and Android users that it will be shut down on March 31. Microsoft pulled back on Cortana last year, but Cortana is still accessible on Windows. The company is also discontinuing Cortana’s support on the Harman Kardon Invoke speaker.

Opera’s Touch iOS web browser app now rebranded just Opera, released a significant update tU.I.t modernized the UI U.I.th a more flat look, a new color palette, reworked text and new icons in the bottom bar and in the “Fast Action” button, which lets you get to favorite destinations quickly. It also adds a built-in Ethereum wallet.

Privacy & Security

China defined new rules over the information apps can collect, saying that users of a short video, news, browser, and utility apps can access essential services on these platforms without providing their info. The new regulation goes into effect on May 1. It covers 39 app categories — also including messaging, online shopping, payments, ride-hailing, short video, Livestream, and mobile games — where it specifies what information is necessary to use the app (e.g., if e-commerce, a user’s phone number, name, address, and payment info).

The Indian government is trying to stop WhatsApp’s controversial privacy policy update with an antitrust investigation into the policy changes to determine the extent of the app’s data-sharing practices enabled through WhatsApp users’ “involuntary consent”.

An investigation by The NYT found that Britain’s top gambling app, Sky Bet, was compiling extensive records about users. The app or one of the data providers it hires to collect users’ information can access users’ banking records, mortgage details, location, and gambling habits.

Apple responded to ProtonVPN’s claims that Apple was standing in the way of human rights by rejecting one of its app updates. The VPN maker attempted to tie the rejection to the coup in Myanmar, saying that people in the country use its app to bypass internet crackdowns and share information about the ongoing “crimes against humanity” in the country.

Apple responded to the attack by noting that it had only asked the developer to reword its description so it doesn’t read like it’s encouraging users to bypass geo-restrictions or content limitations (you know, which would be illegal). And it pointed out that all of Proton’s apps have remained available in Myanmar this whole time.

Facebook caught Chinese hackers using fake personas to target Uyghurs abroad. The social network saw the network of China-based hackers using fake Facebook accounts, posing as activists, journalists, and other sympathetic figures to send the targets to compromised websites. The hacking groups aim to access the targets’ devices by getting them to install malicious apps for surveillance purposes.

A cybersecurity review of TikTok by the University of Toronto’s Citizen Lab says it’s no worse than Facebook in either data privacy or security. This, however, may be a low bar. Scam apps have stolen more than $400 million from users across the App Store and Google, according to a study by Avast. The company reported 204 so-called “fleece are apps” with over a billion combined downloads that trick users into free trials but overcharge them with subscriptions as high as $3,432 per year.

“Apart from the financial harm… users affected by such scams will be less inclined to download apps or engage with app stores. Therefore, these fleece are apples hurt legitimate developers that ethically use the subscription model.” https://t.co/4ec5AtF0s3

— David Barnard (@drbarnard) March 25, 2021

💰 Messaging app Telegram raised over $1 billion through bond sales to multiple investors, including a combined $150 million investment by Mubadala Investment Co. and Abu Dhabi Catalyst Partners, part-owned by the Abu Dhabi state fund. Last week, this column noted that the app had owed its creditors around $700 million by the end of April, per The WSJ’s report.

💰 Fortnite and Houseparty owner Epic Games is reportedly closing on $1 billion in new funding to value its business at $28 billion.

🤝 Twitter acquired the team from API integration platform Reshuffle to work on its developer API platform. The team of seven, including two co-founders, will immediately begin building tools for Twitter developers while Reshuffle’s business is wound down.

💰 Link-in-bio company Linktree, whose mini websites get linked to by creators in your favorite social apps, raised $45 million to develop new social commerce tools. The company says a third of its 12 million users have signed up within the last four months — a trend partially driven by the pandemic.

📈 South Korea’s most prominent travel app, Yanolja, talks with banks to go public through a dual listing in Seoul and overseas. The company is aiming for a $4 billion valuation.

📈 ironSource, a business platform for the app economy, agreed with Thoma Bravo’s blank-check firm to go public via a SPAC at an $11.1 billion valuation.

💰 Ryu Games raised a seed round of $2.3 million for its service that helps developers add cash tournaments to their mobile games. The company aims to be present in a few dozen games this year.

💰 Nigerian fintech Bank raised $2 million for its app that digitizes cash for the unbanked in a round led by Vault.

💰 Mumbai-headquartered Indian fantasy sports app Dream11’s parent firm, Dream Sports, raised $400 million in a round led by TCV, D1 Capital Partners, and Falcon Edge, valuing the business at nearly $5 billion.

💰 Indian social network Public Appraised $41 million six months after its $35 fundraising, valuing the business company $250 million — or more than double the valuation since the prior fundraise. The app has over 50 million users, including over 50,000 elected officials, government authorities, and citizen journalists.

💰 U.K.-based stock trading app Freetrade raised a $69 million Series B from Left Lane Capital. The company is now valued at $366 million. The Robinhood-like app offers free trades and the ability to buy fractional shares.

💰 Indonesian savings and investment app Pluang raised $20 million in pre-Series B funding led by Openspace Ventures. The company offers savings and investment products that allow users to make contributions starting at aA.R.50 cents (USD).

💰 AR A.R.oneer Blippar returns with $5 million in funding after 18 months of repositioning aA.R.a B2B company in tA.R. AR A.R.ace. Blippar’s AR A.RA.R.dio can help brands with A.R.RA.R.. the web and inside their apps or Blippar’s app.


Avatarify is another app benefitting from the current interest in bringing photos to life. We’ve already seen apps like MyHeritage, TokkingHeads, Wombo, and Piñata Farms introduce their ideas in this space — whether it’s recalling long-lost relatives or just making a celeb lip sync to Michael Jackson. Avatar, meanwhile, will let you record a short video which it then uses to animate any photo of your choice — even pictures of art, babies, or pets. The app is moving the charts to No. 28 on the App Store.

Types of vinyl

Vinyl, reviewed this week by iMore and recently by 9to5Mac, is a minimalist music player for Apple Music subscribers. The developer behind the Twitter client Aviary built the app and displayed a spinning vinyl record when playing music. The app also animates a tonearm that aligns with the current playback time and moves in and out when playing and pausing the music. You can also “scrub” the vinyl to seek forwards and backward. Vinyl is available on Mac, iPhone, and iPad.